 |
| Rawpixel/Stock/Getty Images Plus |
Today’s title doesn’t
imply anger or annoyance at Pride (I’m not sure if many people still use the
word “vex” in that way). I mean something else entirely. Long-time readers know
I’m a vexillologist – a flag studier (deriving from “vexillum”, the name of the
square flags the Romans used), and today is World Vexillology Day, a day to
celebrate the world of flags. Today is also the start of LGBT History Month
USA, so what better way to start the month by proudly waving your lgbt flags.In the 21st century people
have been defined more diverse genders and sexualities. Most express their
diversity with their own flag, and there’s a growing number of these all the
time. The Unity Pride Flag Project is endeavouring to display all known
diversity flags in one huge flag. The project began in the USA after a group of
friends thought about an all-inclusive flag containing all the colours of every
gender and sexuality flag. Very quickly it became apparent that there were too
many colours (breaking one of the “principles” of flag design, see below).
Instead it was decided to have every diversity flag joined together in one long
flag.
If you want to know more
about this project you can visit their website here. If you want to know what
each flag represents you can visit their Facebook photo page here.
The principles of flag
design were formulated by vexillologists around the world and published by the
North American Vexillological Association in 2006. These aren’t legal
requirements but are guidelines for good design. Here are their recommended
principles:
1) KEEP IT SIMPLE. It
should be easy enough for a child to copy from memory, and instantly
identifiable when seen high up on a flag pole. The back of the flag should be
an exact mirror image of the front.
2) USE MEANINGFUL
SYMBOLISM, whether in the
colours, layout or symbols.
3) USE FEW COLOURS,
preferably 2 or 3 contrasting colours from the standard colour set (red,
yellow, green, blue, black, white).
4) NO LETTERING OR SEALS.
No words. State seals are designed to be seen close-up on paper, not high up on
a flag pole.
5) BE DISTINCTIVE OR
RELATED. Don’t copy existing flags. If expressing a connection to an existing
community make the design distinctive enough so that a difference can be seen
when it is on a flag pole.
I would add two more
principles:
6) BE AWARE OF
PROPORTIONS. Most designs look best on a rectangle. Don’t be afraid to use
square or triangular flags if it suits the design, as long as it can still be
flown on a flag pole. No curved edges.
7) DO YOUR RESEARCH. Make
sure your flag doesn’t already exist. Check the meaning of emblems and symbols
- don’t risk abuse by designing a flag with, say, neo-Nazi symbols (take note,
Extinction Rebellion).
There are many good flags
that have exceptions to these principles (e.g. Rainbow Pride flag and the South
African national flag), as do many flags designed before these principles were
formulated.
You may not realise that
international law regards flags as belonging unconditionally to the people.
There are a few emblems and symbols (including the Red Cross, the Olympic
rings, corporate logos, coats of arms) that are protected by law and should be
avoided and not used without permission. Many young lgbt flag designers assume
they own the copyright on their design. They retain credit as designer and can,
if permissible, register copyright in their own country on any new symbols or
emblems, but as soon as they make their flag public it becomes public property
– anyone can produce their flag.
Something that really does
get me “vexed” in the meaning of “annoyed” are the many examples of bad flag
designs on the Unity Pride Facebook page. Many are designed by young
inexperienced flag designers. Of course, not everyone can be a graphic designer
and I have no quarrel with their gender identities, but very few of their flags
are “distinctive”. Others are a mash-up of existing flags. It would be
difficult to distinguish any of them on an actual flag pole, which makes the
design (not the gender identity) pointless. The biggest failure is the long
Unity Pride Flag itself. Being composed of hundreds of smaller flags makes it
impracticable. If you can’t fly it on a flag pole it’s not a flag, simple as
that. It’s a quilt.
Don’t get me wrong. I
adore what the people at Unity Pride are doing. Anything that promotes the
awareness and cultural importance (and dangers) of flags is a good thing. But,
from a vexillologist’s point of view, the end result is brave but
disappointing.
Another flag that has me
vexed is the Unity Pride infinity symbol. The idea behind it was to show many
colours of lgbt flags on the left loop. On that point alone it breaks the 3rd
principle, even if it’s not compulsory. It’s the presence of the infinity
symbol that is more problematic. The infinity symbol had been used as the
emblem of the ethnic Métis people of Canada since 1816. In 2014 the Canadian
government gave the infinity symbol protected status. It can only be used by
the Métis people, or to represent them, or used in mathematics. By implication
it applies to any nation outside Canada where Métis people live. Its use since
2014 by anyone else (including Unity Pride) isn’t illegal, but it IS cultural
appropriation. Some places may ban the Unity Pride infinity flag because it can
be seen as an abuse of the Métis emblem.
Several other uses of the
infinity symbol pre-date 2014 (e.g. autism awareness and some bisexual flags)
but the law is not retrospective. There are thousands of other symbols in the
history of the planet that can be adopted for a flag, and many more can be
created, why use one that’s already in use?
Finally, here’s a
community flag designed in 2016 containing the infinity symbol that was used
before it became protected. It’s an example of a good flag design. It was
designed by Twainbow, an American organisation which supports lgbt people on
the autism spectrum, like myself, and made its first appearance at Houston
Pride. The infinity symbol was first adopted for autism awareness in 2004 by
the Aspies For Freedom group in the USA.